Transparency Maldives
Multiple vacancies


Advertise your job/event/promo on Minivan News



Page added on November 1, 2012

Bill on death penalty drafted, unclear on action on past sentences: AG Shakoor

Bill on death penalty drafted, unclear on action on past sentences: AG Shakoor thumbnail

Attorney General (AG) Azima Shakoor stated on Thursday that the government’s bill on implementing death penalty would be made public early in the coming week.

Speaking at a press conference in Velaanaage, Shakoor confirmed that the AG’s office had completed drafting the bill, which was now in the final stages of discussion. She confirmed that the bill would be made public on the office’s website in the coming week, stating the matter “is very much connected to public sentiments and a large number of people feel this matter needs a fast solution”.

Saying that “it was a pity” that three weeks had passed in the drafting stage, Shakoor said that unlike most other bills, the death penalty implementation bill was going through processes of in-depth research and further discussions among a high-level group appointed by the government.

According to Shakoor, the research took much longer than the state had expected, adding that the AG office had included the legal systems of Medina, Egypt and America in its research.

“I would like to point out that the death penalty is still implemented in over 50 countries across the world even today. Not all of these are even Islamic states. Nor is murder the only crime for which the sentence is given. For example, some countries sentence people to death for being caught trying to bring in narcotics to the country. We are considering all of these points and have made a comparative legal assessment,” Shakoor explained.

Other crimes besides murder which are punishable by death according to Islamic Sharia include apostasy, adultery, sodomy, rape and high treason.

“We need to conduct an academic exercise since we are trying to do this through a rather weak penal code,” Shakoor said.

“If this can be done before the penal code pending in parliament is passed, it might be best to include this as part of that code. Right now, we have drafted this with the thought that if the penal code gets passed up front, then this can be passed as a separate act on death penalty.”

Shakoor said that the bill was important as the current practice was to charge murder convicts under Article 88 of the existing penal code.

Article 88 of the Penal Code states that disobedience to order is a crime, while Article 88(c) details that if the result of violating the article leads to a death, the case should be dealt with according to Islamic Sharia.

Shakoor provided details of the drafted bill, stating it would be looking at the investigation stages, prosecution stages, sentencing and the implementation of sentences.

“The act looks into deciding on the number of judges who will sit on the sentencing panel. Furthermore it considers the rights of the family, the rights of the murder victim, the rights of the victim’s family, the final rights of the convict during sentencing,” Shakoor stated.

Responding to a question regarding how those sentenced to death prior to the bill being ratified would be dealt with, Shakoor said “it is difficult to give a straightforward answer as the final discussions on the bill have not yet been completed.”

“We too believe that answers to that must come to light through how this bill is composed. However, I believe that a solution must be provided even for past cases. So the act will be drafted to reflect that. You can see for yourselves once the bill is made public,” Shakoor replied.

“When an act is passed which explicitly spells out implementation [of the death penalty], then I believe the benefits of it must be carried to even past cases.”

Among a number of other cases, a young couple charged with the murder of lawyer Ahmed Najeeb were sentenced to death by the Criminal Court in July, a few days after the UN Human Rights Committee (UNHRC) asked the Maldivian state to enact legislation to officially abolish the death penalty. The statement said “the state itself has admitted that capital punishment does not deter crime.”

FacebookTwitterEmailGoogle GmailGoogle+BeboPocketShare

11 Comments on "Bill on death penalty drafted, unclear on action on past sentences: AG Shakoor"

  1. Majeed on Thu, 1st Nov 2012 7:35 PM 

    88(c) details that if the result of violating the article leads to a death, the case should be dealt with according to Islamic Sharia.
    Question is ; Is Islamic Sharia incomplete?

  2. Hashim Amla on Thu, 1st Nov 2012 8:53 PM 

    And you trust the judiciary to get it right? 100% of the time?

  3. LipService on Thu, 1st Nov 2012 10:17 PM 

    “Shakoor said that unlike most other bills, the death penalty implementation bill was going through processes of in-depth research and further discussions among a high-level group appointed by the government.”

    So Azima Shakoor admits that bills are being drafted and submitted to Majlis with no research at all? Only as dreamt up by Kutti Nasheed, I suppose.

  4. ha ha haaa on Fri, 2nd Nov 2012 9:52 AM 

    Spinning a yarn for Nasheed’s head….Noose gets tighter!

  5. MFBI on Fri, 2nd Nov 2012 11:21 AM 

    An 11 year old minor conceives on an island.

    How about implementing some new rules on child abuse? What kind of sentence does the guy who ‘poked’ her deserve?

    Death penalty discussions are political to get the government through the elections. After that, the idea would be dropped and crime would resurface again.

    What a joke!

  6. Wives and Concubines on Fri, 2nd Nov 2012 2:52 PM 

    Why stop at the death penalty? How about chopping off limbs of thieves and stoning adulterers?

    If just the death penalty is implemented and the rest is ignored conveniently, it is more evidence that this is being done by political parties, especially adhaalath to just try and get more votes, power and money which they can then spend on booze and prostitutes in bangkok.

  7. ToxicT on Fri, 2nd Nov 2012 5:32 PM 

    Dodgy judiciary + Death Penalty +recipe for disaster (although that depends on who is looking at it of course) Bit obvious innit? So predictable (as usual) Brawn vs brain, clearly.

  8. ali rasheed on Fri, 2nd Nov 2012 9:26 PM 

    What if Maumoon and Isthafa have to pay for their criminal acts? Would the death sentence still be implemented?

  9. Dhivehi Hanguraama on Fri, 2nd Nov 2012 10:04 PM 

    An ineffective judiciary only means that more people shal be garrotted or hanged. This is not problematic at all and, indeed, shall be of a great benefit in bringing morality back to this nation of miscrants, deviants and harlots.

    The more people that hang by the noose, the more shall the MalDeviant fear death. The consideration of his prospects in the afterlife may but compel him to increase his virtue and faith. More importantly, the consideration of this prospect might prompt our harlots to stop being harlots and also turn towards virtue. From virtuous wombs does virtuous offspring spring forth.

    Implement the death penalty. Implement virtue. Alhamdulillaah.

  10. HassanK on Sat, 3rd Nov 2012 8:02 AM 

    Talk about walking before you can crawl. There isn’t even a half decent legal system with an evidence law let alone the fact that there isn’t capable and non-corrupt legal experts. All everyone wants is death penalty. No one seem to care how the laws are weak and lawyers and judges are either retarded or corrupted. So they don’t care that the conviction is reached through completely un-Islamic system but they want Islamic punishment at the end. Maldivians are too smart in their own heat for their own good.

  11. Barbarian on Sun, 4th Nov 2012 9:46 AM 

    What about chopping limbs and hands?????

  • Sinhala_Man: I’m so glad I mentioned to Mr Rankin at the British Car Day in Colombo that there is Evil under the Sun in the Maldives. Do you see what a small...
  • Maldivian: As long as corrupt judiciaries continue to protect child abusers, and weak people continue to try and appease them, child abuse will remain rampant in this...
  • Maldivian: “Reality check” may keep repeating the lies of his masters for a wad of cash. But there’s no way an ‘intoxicated man’ could...
  • Maldivian: Legal action on their part only works if people allow themselves to be herded into the death camps.
  • Maldivian: @Hero See those fine wines you’re drinking right now in your 5-star hotel? Look closely at the shipping label and you’ll notice it came from...
  • Maldivian: So, you called police ‘traitors’? I don’t think that’s fair. After all, they’re heroin-peddling bags of feces that wear body...
  • Maldivian: Well, its your fault for supporting the fake regime, white meat.
  • Maldivian: According to active surveillance in the police, these gangsters were later freed with a pat on the back. The police are lying. They’re not...


Torture victims in the Maldives tell their stories